COMMITTEE AGENDA MEMORANDUM
Capital Improvement Program Committee
Government Code § 84308 Applies: Yes ☐ No ☒
(If “YES” Complete Attachment A - Gov. Code § 84308)
SUBJECT: title
Receive Report on Procurement Elements and Contracting Approach for the Anderson Dam Seismic Retrofit Project (ADSRP), Project No. 91864005.
End
RECOMMENDATION: Recommendation
Receive report on the construction contractor prequalification process, best value bid selection criteria, sole source construction materials, contract retention, and proposed liquidated damages and incentive approach for ADSRP.
Body
SUMMARY:
In alignment with Valley Water’s procurement authority under California Public Contract Code Section 21163, and the Board’s approval of the Best Value Procurement method on October 8, 2024 the Anderson Dam Seismic Retrofit Project (ADSRP) construction contractor will be selected on the basis of Best Value. This provision specifically authorizes Valley Water to evaluate construction bids for ADSRP using both price and non-price factors such as contractor qualifications, technical capabilities, and past performance, rather than awarding solely based on the lowest bid.
The purpose of this agenda item is to provide an overview of key elements related to the procurement process for ADSRP. It includes a summary of the current construction contractor prequalification process, an overview of the best value evaluation criteria, a review of sole source construction materials, construction contract retention, and the proposed use of liquidated damages and incentive to ensure timely delivery of critical milestones for ADSRP. These items are presented to inform the Committee about the procurement process, ahead of the Board considering the authorization to advertise the plans and specifications for ADSRP.
1. Construction Contractor Prequalification
Staff completed the Construction Contractor Prequalification phase, the first step in the two-step Best Value procurement process for ADSRP. This process began with the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Committee’s support for the Request for Prequalification Application (RFPA) and Best Value contractor selection methodology on September 16, 2024. The Board approved this approach on October 8, 2024, and the RFPA was subsequently released through Valley Water’s online bidding portal PlanetBids on December 2, 2024.
Extensive industry outreach followed to ensure broad awareness and participation through PlanetBids, with outreach going out to the following:
• 2,014 entities
o 822 small and disadvantaged businesses
o 271 local and regional firms
o 26 plan rooms and chambers of commerce
The RFPA was also distributed to the Santa Clara and San Benito Counties Building and Construction Trades Council, reaching an additional 500 contractors and 70 union representatives. The Industry Day, a pre-advertisement event hosted by Valley Water for contractors to learn about the project, was published in the American Society of Civil Engineers, the American Water Works Association, and the Beavers - an organization managed by heavy engineering construction companies. Sixty contractors attended the Industry Day on October 18, 2024, and fifty attended the Prequalification Conference on December 18, 2024. By the close of the RFPA period, 91 firms had registered as planholders in PlanetBids.
Applications were evaluated through a pass/fail process that considered both financial capacity and three core technical qualifications:
• Dam construction experience on projects exceeding $150 million, with at least one embankment dam over 50 feet (since 2000);
• Tunnel construction experience in weak rock or mixed ground using drill-and-blast methods; and
• Demonstrated management of public infrastructure projects valued at $500 million or more.
The nine-member evaluation committee included scoring members and subject matter experts in engineering, finance, and risk/insurance. Full application submissions were received on February 19, 2025, from the following firms:
• Barnard Construction Company (Bozeman, MT)
• Flatiron West Inc. - Sukut Construction, LLC Joint Venture (Concord, CA)
• Kiewit Infrastructure West Company (Fairfield, CA)
Following technical and financial review, reference checks, and internal approvals, Valley Water finalized and published the list of prequalified contractors on May 29, 2025. All three applicants met the established criteria and are invited to proceed to the next stage of procurement.
2. Best Value Evaluation Criteria
To support a balanced contractor selection process for ADSRP and comply with the statutory requirements, the procurement process will implement an evaluation model that integrates both technical and cost considerations. Given the project's complexity and public safety significance, the evaluation criteria are structured to prioritize contractor qualifications, technical approach, and risk management capabilities, while maintaining price competitiveness.
The Best Value evaluation model for ADSRP will use a 60% weighting for Technical Submittal and 40% for Price Submittal.
Technical Evaluation (60 pts):
• Covers approaches to management, scheduling risk, dam, outlet works, and spillway.
• Management also includes safety, environmental, and quality aspects.
These elements are scored using adjectival ratings (Exceptional to Unsatisfactory), which are then converted to numeric scores that are summed up, ensuring that a perfect score cannot exceed 60 points.
Price Evaluation (40 pts):
• The lowest price proposal receives the full 40 points.
• Other price proposals receive proportionally reduced scores based on deviation from the lowest bid.
This weighting aligns with other major California public agencies (such as the Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, and San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency) for large-scale infrastructure projects.
3. Sole Source Justification for Temporary Spillway
The Anderson Dam Seismic Retrofit Project involves the removal and reconstruction of most of the existing embankment dam with a new, well-compacted zoned embankment, along with the construction of new low-level and high-level outlets to meet DSOD emergency evacuation requirements. The project also includes the removal, replacement, and extension of the concrete spillway to accommodate the probable maximum flood, as well as other dam improvements. Upon completion, Anderson Reservoir will be restored to its original storage capacity. During the five-year construction period, the spillway will be temporarily unavailable, increasing flood risk. To mitigate this, a series of four temporary spillways will be constructed and subsequently removed each year to ensure safe stormwater passage and reduce downstream risk during the winter seasons.
The only option that meets the design, constructability, and schedule requirements for the temporary spillways on the Anderson Dam Seismic Retrofit Project is Shoreblock EPEC SD-900 OCT. Alternative materials, such as roller-compacted concrete (RCC), were evaluated but found to be unsuitable due to longer construction timelines, increased waste, and incompatibility with the construction sequence; therefore, the Project intends to use Shoreblock EPEC SD-900 OCT, an articulated concrete block (ACB) system, as the only approved material for building and removing temporary spillways during the winterization phases of ADSRP.
Key reasons for this sole source include:
• Shoreblock has been tested and confirmed in flume/physical models.
• Shoreblock’s performance has been reviewed and approved by the Board of Consultants, FERC, and DSOD.
• Shoreblock is licensed exclusively to Premier Concrete Products Inc. and Contech Engineered Solutions.
• Shoreblock system offers removable, rapidly deployable erosion protection essential during winter.
4. Progress Payment Retention
In accordance with California Public Contract Code Section 7201, Valley Water’s standard construction contracts include a 5% retention from each payment to the contractor. This amount is withheld until the project is completed and accepted, and it serves as a financial incentive for the contractor to satisfactorily complete all work, including punch list items and closeout documentation.
Section 7201 sets the default retention cap at 5% for public entities but allows for a higher retention amount if the agency makes a finding during a properly noticed public meeting that the project is “substantially complex” and requires additional retention to ensure performance.
Although the Anderson Dam Seismic Retrofit Project (ADSRP) is a highly complex and large-scale public safety project, staff proposes to maintain the standard 5% retention on all progress payments made to the contractor. This retention approach aligns with industry norms for projects of similar scale and complexity and is considered sufficient to protect Valley Water’s interests while ensuring continued contractor performance through project completion.
5. Liquidated Damages and Incentive Structure
To promote on-time completion of critical construction milestones and minimize flood risk associated with schedule delays, staff is proposing a structured liquidated damages and incentive framework for ADSRP.
Failure to achieve the two key milestones, Completion of the Upstream Diversion Tunnel and Completion of Stage 1B Interim Dam, will be subject to liquidated damages of $25 million. These milestones are schedule-sensitive, and failure to meet the completion deadline results in a one-year delay due to seasonal constraints. The $25 million figure reflects anticipated environmental mitigation and monitoring costs that would be incurred during an additional year of dewatering and site impact.
Staff is also proposing a $25 million incentive for the early completion of the Stage 2B Interim Dam. The purpose of this incentive is to encourage early and timely completion of this critical milestone for public safety and flood risk reduction. The incentive is structured to drive contractor performance and ensure this milestone is prioritized without triggering adversarial claims.
Next Steps
As part of the upcoming Board action on ADSRP, staff will recommend that the Board:
1. Authorize the advertisement of the construction contract to the prequalified contractors, who will be invited to submit both a Technical Proposal and a Price Proposal in accordance with the Best Value procurement process; and
2. Approve a sole-source designation for the acquisition of temporary spillway materials necessary for project execution.
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE AND EQUITY IMPACT:
These actions support Valley Water’s mission to provide safe, reliable infrastructure for all communities. The integrity and timely execution of ADSRP safeguards regional water supply and flood safety.
ATTACHMENTS:
Attachment 1: PowerPoint
UNCLASSIFIED MANAGER:
Manager
Tony Ndah, 408-630-2208